Indiana Criminal Defense Attorneys

A Collaborative Team of Aggressive, Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialists

When you are facing criminal accusations as serious as murder or sex offenses, you need a team of defense attorneys who have the skill and experience to get you out of your legal dilemma. The Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialists at The Criminal Defense Team have over 90 years of combined experience representing clients accused of a range of crimes in Indiana. Criminal defense is the only law the firm practices, and the team can provide you with the aggressive advocacy you need to protect your rights, freedom, and future.

Need experienced criminal defense? Call (317) 565-2221 to schedule a consultation!

Why Choose Our Criminal Attorneys in Indiana?

Don’t leave your fate in the hands of an inexperienced attorney when you’re facing a potential prison sentence. The Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Wiley PC is ready to take your case and go to battle for you in court. Whether you were arrested or charged with a misdemeanor or felony, the attorneys at the firm will review the circumstances of your alleged crime and determine your legal options. The Criminal Defense Team takes a collaborative approach to every case they handle, and you can count on multiple attorneys working together on your single case. The attorneys will leave no stone unturned in their mission to poke holes in the prosecutor’s arguments and disprove the evidence presented against you during the trial.

You deserve the right, experienced professionals in your corner to ensure the best possible outcome. With different strengths, contacts, and experiences, the lawyers at The Criminal Defense Team will bring a well-rounded and multilevel approach to your case. When you hire our Indiana criminal defense law firm, they will assemble a team that matches your needs. You can expect to have two lawyers and a paralegal working on your case, as well as full access to the entire team at the office. 

In need of legal defense representation for criminal charges in Indiana? Contact The Criminal Defense Team of Baldwin Perry & Wiley PC for your free initial consultation. Our Indiana criminal defense attorneys will happily meet with you to discuss your case and the type of defense you need.

In The News

  • Lesser Charge in Castleton Tragedy

    Lesser Charge in Castleton Tragedy

    The Indianapolis community has been closely following the trial of Gaylyn Morris, who was recently found guilty of voluntary manslaughter after an event outside Tilly's Pub and Grill in Castleton. A significant point of contention during the trial was the defense's plea: they urged the jury to consider Morris guilty of an offense less severe than murder, citing her actions as a result of sudden heat after enduring years of mistreatment by Smith. The jury's verdict came after intense deliberations, and sentencing is now scheduled for September 21. Keep an eye on our website for continued coverage of this case and other local news stories.

    Learn More
  • Closing Arguments in Gaylyn Morris Case

    Closing Arguments in Gaylyn Morris Case

    Closing arguments have commenced in the case of Gaylyn Morris. She faces murder charges after allegedly running over her boyfriend with a car.

    Learn More


  • NBTA
  • Indiana Bar Association
  • INDY Bar
  • Hamilton County Bar

    Client Reviews

    • “We would recommend the Criminal Defense Team to anyone.” - Vicki
    • “This is Mr. Andrew Baldwin’s specialty and he knows his stuff!” - Donita
    • “I feel they genuinely care about others and work together quite well as a team.” - Brandon

    Our Board Certifications

    Board-Certified Criminal Trial Specialist

    More than 15,000 lawyers practice in Indiana, but only 5 can claim the title of Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialist. Amazingly, 4 of those 5 certified specialists work closely together in the same law firm…our firm. Our team has been assembled by design, not happenstance.

    Board-Certification* is an elite title reserved for those lawyers who have expertise and dedication in one area of law as well as extensive trial experience. We are proud of that title and what it represents. Our Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialists fight for our clients and work with all of our lawyers every day to help obtain the best possible outcome for our clients.

    In Indiana, attorneys can become board certified in a specific area of law through the Indiana State Bar Association. Board certification indicates that the attorney has demonstrated a high level of expertise and experience in their practice area, and clients can be confident that they are receiving quality legal representation from a qualified professional. Board Certification Matters. Check here to see if any other lawyer you are talking with are certified.
     QR Code
    You wouldn’t want a general practice doctor who is not board certified to handle your heart condition, why would you want a general practice law firm with no Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialists to handle your criminal case?

    National Board of Trial Advocacy (NBTA)

    *Andrew Baldwin, Kathie Perry, Maxwell Wiley, and Kelly Pyle are certified Criminal Trial Specialists by the National Board of Trial Advocacy (NBTA), a nonprofit organization that certifies attorneys of various legal focuses. To earn an NTBA certification, an attorney must demonstrably show the highest levels of trial experience, competence and integrity.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Our team will fight for you
    • What about a public defender?
      A public defender is a state-appointed attorney that comes to your aid if you are charged with a crime and cannot afford to hire an attorney. Often, public defenders get a bad name. However, just like anything else, there are good public defenders and bad public defenders. In our opinion, there are also good private lawyers and bad private lawyers.

      If you are accused of a crime and want the best attorney or team of attorneys to represent you, then you should look into the credentials of the lawyer or law firm. How many cases do they fight to trial? How long have they been practicing? Do they work as a team? These are a few of the questions that you should be finding the answers to. Hiring the right lawyer to take care of your case is of monumental importance.

      Few lawyers in the state of Indiana have the experience, skill, and knowledge to match up to our team of lawyers, whether they are public defenders or private lawyers.
    • What should I do if I am ever arrested?
      Remember that, according to the Miranda rights, that you have the right to remain silent. This means you do not have to say anything to the police that will lead to your incrimination, so please keep that in mind during the process. According to the 5th amendment of the constitution, you do not have to answer any questions the police ask, especially after being arrested. You also have the right to a lawyer and should seek the help of an attorney as soon as you can.

      Let a criminal defense lawyer do the talking for you-we have extensive training on the right things to do and say even while an investigation is pending before you are arrested. Talk to us first. Our help can be invaluable to you at this time. Contact us if you need assistance.
    • What does it mean to be a Board-Certified* Criminal Trial Specialists?

      Rule 7.4. of the Indiana Rules of Professional Conduct provides direction for any lawyer who wants to become a “specialist” in an area of law:

      1. A lawyer shall not state or imply that the lawyer is a specialist in a particular field of law, unless:
        1. The lawyer has been certified as a specialist by an Independent Certifying Organization accredited by the Indiana Commission for Continuing Legal Education pursuant to Admission and Discipline Rule 30; and,
        2. The certifying organization is identified in the communication.

      In order to become Board-Certified in Indiana as a “Criminal Law Specialist” it requires that the attorney meet the criteria of the National Board of Trial Advocacy. The criteria to become Board-Certified by the National Board of Trial Advocacy are rigorous. Only those attorneys who dedicate a high percentage of their practice to criminal defense, and who have acquired a high number of days in trial, will be even considered. Even then, the candidate must pass a difficult day-long test that is put together by some of the finest criminal lawyers in the nation. Not everyone passes this test, as failing the test is not infrequent. Even if the candidate passes the test, judges and other attorneys must provide confidential assessments of the attorneys skill-level and abilities in the area of criminal law to the National Board of Trial Advocacy.

      Becoming a Board-Certified Criminal Law Specialist is so difficult, and requires such a dedication to criminal law, that of the over 15,000 licensed lawyers in the state of Indiana, only 5 exist that hold that title. 4 of them — Andy Baldwin, Kathie Perry, Max Wiley, and Kelly Pyle — work in our law firm for the Criminal Defense Team of The Criminal Defense Team, and collectively have been Board-Certified for over 5 years.”*

      *Andrew Baldwin, Kathie Perry, Maxwell Wiley, and Kelly Pyle are recognized as Board Certified Criminal Trial Advocates by the National Board of Trial Advocacy
    • What is the difference between felony and misdemeanor charges?
      The state of Indiana categorizes all criminal charges by level of severity, including the total value of stolen property, who, if anyone, was injured, if weapons were involved in a crime, if you have prior convictions, and a number of other factors. Felony charges are more severe and therefore carry higher potential penalties, including harsh prison sentences and high fines. Misdemeanors, on the other hand, can yield 60 days in jail and a fine of up to $500 for the least serious, or class C, offenses.
    • What are civil rights offenses?
      When you’ve been arrested, your civil rights can be violated by unscrupulous or negligent officials. This includes police brutality, negligent medical professionals, invasion of privacy or violations of due process during an investigation, or injuries that can occur from an arrest. When your rights have been violated, it’s important you seek representation from our Franklin criminal defense lawyers. We have represented clients on civil rights cases all over southern and south-central Indiana.
    • How much do you charge?
      First of all, our initial consultation is always free. You may be able to learn quite a bit about your case and how we would defend it and what type of results you might expect from our consultation, because we spend as much time as necessary to discuss your case before you make a decision to hire us. Hiring a criminal defense lawyer who is essentially in charge of a major part of your life and perhaps your freedom is a huge decision. We are happy to talk to you in our office or on the phone so you can make that decision with as much information as possible.

      Once you indicate that you have a desire to hire us, we will discuss cost. Our prices vary depending on a variety of factors. We charge a flat-fee, which means you will be given a quote that will be determined by our firm. Once you agree to pay this fee, there will be no further charges beyond the agreed-upon amount. You can pay upfront or in certain situations, we may agree on a payment plan that will usually require a substantial portion of the overall fee to be paid upfront (usually at least 50% of the fee) then we can usually work out a payment plan on the remaining balance. Factors that influence the price include how severe your charges are, how complex the case is, the number of pending charges, how urgent the matter is, the amount of investigation needed, prior criminal history, as well as a variety of other factors.

      When you hire our firm, the Criminal Defense Team of The Criminal Defense Team, you are primarily paying for our reputation as criminal defense lawyers and trial lawyers. You are also paying for our time, experience, knowledge and know-how. To speak with our lawyers about using our services, contact us. The case evaluation is always free.
    • Can you get my charges dismissed? If not, what outcome can I expect?
      No attorney can predict the future. If you are interviewing a lawyer who promises you any outcome, we suggest you run out of his/her office as that is unethical and should not be tolerated. It most likely means that they simply want your money and will promise you a sunny day in order to get your money. It is not uncommon for our firm to have criminal charges, ranging from misdemeanors to felonies dismissed, and perhaps your case can be dismissed as well.

      However, statistically speaking it is unlikely that your case will be dismissed. Every case is different and every outcome may be different. In our firm we are willing to give you an idea of a range of likely outcomes based upon the facts of your case, as well as the charge itself, the particular court you may be in and the prosecutor you may be dealing with. We think that part of what we get paid to do is to use our vast experience to provide you guidance on what you are really facing. We won’t lie to you and offer you a sunny day if there are clouds in the sky, nor will we frighten you into taking a plea agreement just to get the case over with, if we believe that you should continue to fight for a dismissal, a better plea or a win at trial. Ultimately, while the case is pending we will tell you what we think is the likely outcome at various stages. Our opinion on those outcomes may change as the evidence rolls in or as the case progresses. We cannot promise what will happen, but may provide at least a pretty good idea of what is likely to happen based upon our vast experience. Our predictions of the outcome of a client’s case rarely fall outside the range that we predict and provide for the client. This is because our lawyers have done this for so long that we have a very good idea about what the outcome may be. Some cases are so strange or have so many variables that we just don’t know or have a good feel for the outcome. If this is the case, we will tell you.

      No matter the case, if you’ve been charged with a criminal act, you need to seek legal help immediately and we will give you our thoughts. We are here to help you, so call (317) 565-2221 as soon as you can.
    • 4 Board Certified Criminal Trial Specialists by the National Board of Trial Advocacy
    • Our attorneys have 90 years of combined criminal trial experience

    Why choose us?

    Contact us today!

    The Criminal Defense Team has over 90 years of combined experience representing clients and defending them against the charges they’re facing. We know your future and freedom are at stake. You can depend on us to protect your rights and fight hard to reach a favorable outcome in your case. When you hire us, we will provide the guidance and support you need to get through this difficult time in your life. You can depend on our legal team to remain by your side until the very end.

    If you’re facing charges for arson in Indiana, do not hesitate to contact The Criminal Defense Team immediately. Call (317) 565-2221 for a free consultation.

    • Please enter your first name.
    • Please enter your last name.
    • Please enter your phone number.
      This isn't a valid phone number.
    • Please enter your email address.
      This isn't a valid email address.
    • Please make a selection.
    • Please enter a message.
    • By submitting, you agree to be contacted about your request & other information using automated technology. Message frequency varies. Msg & data rates may apply. Text STOP to cancel. Acceptable Use Policy